Unexpected theme switching behavior and keyboard background flicker
Description:
I’ve noticed some slightly unexpected behavior when switching themes. Maybe I’m misunderstanding how the theme settings are supposed to work, but here’s what happens:
When the appearance is set to Auto (with Dark Mode enabled on my iPhone), and the theme selector at the bottom is set to Light, selecting any theme from the list (whether Light or Dark) only changes the selector’s appearance. If I go back to the home screen and then open Appearance settings again, the theme selection has reverted.
The same thing happens when I manually set the appearance to Light and then try selecting a Dark theme from the list.
I’m not entirely sure if this is intentional, but the behavior feels a little confusing, so I thought I’d bring it to your attention.
There’s also a small visual glitch with the keyboard background. When editing a note with the keyboard open, tapping the back arrow causes the keyboard’s background color to briefly flash on the screen before disappearing.
Device: iPhone 17
OS: iOS 27.2
Log in to comment and vote
Comments3
Gary Bacon (pixelbud)
Nov 18
The clearer theme picker is in Smolpad 1.4.2, out today for iPhone and iPad. Settings › Appearance now shows both of your themes at once: a card for When light and a card for When dark, with a line that says which one you are choosing for. I have not been able to reproduce the keyboard flash yet, so this post stays open for it.
Gary Bacon (pixelbud)
Nov 16
Hi Gary, (great name 😄 )
I’ve been thinking about how to best show this too.
So appearance is what mode the app is running in: Auto matches your iPhone’s settings. If your phone is always on Dark mode, then the app will consider itself in dark mode too.
The tabs show which theme you’ve sent for light and which theme you’ve set for dark mode. (I see how this could be read as grouping tabs, only show me light or only show me dark.) The purpose of this was that if for whatever reason you wanted to have Solarized Dark for light mode, and Everforest Dark for dark mode. So two dark themes set based on “time of day” if Auto is set.
I can see how this would be confusing. If the tab pill shows Light theme as active, what is selected below it is your light theme. If the tab has Dark theme selected, what you select is applied as your dark theme. The tab pill updates based on what theme you have selected for that mode.
In the short term, I’m going to make it so that when you click on Light - in Smolpad’s appearance area - it would make the light theme tab active. And when you click on Dark, it makes the Dark theme active to reinforce this.
Will look into the keyboard issue too.
Thanks for letting me know!
Another Gary
Nov 17
Ahh, now I get it! Thanks, Gary 😉